Culture of migration: Exploring Migration as a Normative Behavior

Organizer: Saroj Koirala (skoirala@jyu.fi)

Time: Thursday 7.11., session 1 at 13.00-14.30 and session 2 at 16.15-17.45

In this session, scholars, researchers, and practitioners will discuss the cultural dimensions of migration, examining how migration becomes ingrained into the collective consciousness of certain communities, transforming it into a normative behavior. The session will explore migration not only as a rational decision influenced by external micro- or macro-level factors but also as a cultural product perpetuated by learned behavior and societal expectations.

The session welcomes diverse perspectives and interdisciplinary approaches to explore migration culture, drawing connections between anthropology, sociology, cultural studies, and migration studies. Topics for discussion may include:

1. Case studies of communities where migration has become a cultural norm, exploring the historical, social, and economic factors that have contributed to this phenomenon.
2. Examination of the role of cultural values, traditions, networks, and familial expectations in shaping migration behavior within different societies.
3. Analysis of the interaction between individual agency and cultural determinants in migration decision-making processes.
4. Exploration of the challenges and opportunities associated with preserving cultural identity and heritage in migrant communities.
5. Comparative studies of migration cultures across different regions and ethnic groups, highlighting variations and commonalities.

The session encourages presenters to engage with the conference theme by considering how understanding the cultural underpinnings of migration can foster greater empathy, dialogue, and collaboration across diverse communities. The session will be conducted in English, but contributions in other languages (possibly Finnish and Swedish) are welcome, to enrich the discussion and promote inclusivity.

Abstracts

Session 1

Garima Bhandari, Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, India: If People Don’t, Why Would Devta Stay? The Culture of Migration in Western Himalayan Communities

Rural communities in the Global South are significantly impacted by the process of migration, which has altered village dynamics and sparked discussions among social scientists examining migration’s relationship to development and social change. While villages in several parts of South Asia experience circular or semi-permanent movement involving repeated and cyclical movements and altering village culture, many villages of the western Himalayan region are witnessing the contrasting trend towards permanent migration, resulting in the formation of thousands of Abandoned Villages or popularly known as Ghost Villages. This phenomenon has brought significant changes in the socio-political, economic and cultural spheres of these rural areas, which has rarely been figured as an explicit object of research. This study uses the Social transformation lens to analyse the changes and transformations brought about by out-migration in the peripheral depopulating villages. Drawing on a qualitative approach, this study delves into the Culture of migration in a hilly village in Uttarakhand and how it has evolved over time, resulting in the disintegration of the village structure as a whole.

The study focuses on understanding how migration influences and shapes the various dimensions of rural areas, ultimately leading to major shifts in dominant political, economic, agricultural and socio-cultural relationships. Furthermore, it discusses the role of the state in perpetuating migration from rural areas towards urban areas, forming two opposite poles that are unlikely to be bridged. It concludes that in order to prevent villages from becoming abandoned, there should be an effort to develop a comprehensive strategy to address the challenges faced by the mountainous communities.

 

Chisoka Simões, University of Minho: Braga, Portugal: Two Millennia of Migrations and Cultural Transfers

Mobility and migration are intrinsic human traits that have shaped the world. Recently, the discourse surrounding migration has shifted, often portraying it as a threat due to the rise of ethnonationalism in Europe. Grounded in Critical Heritage Studies, with theories of transnationalism and cultural memory, this research analyses migration as a normative behaviour in Braga, highlighting its continuous role in shaping the city’s 2000-year history. Using historical registries, toponymy, and other cultural practices of Braga, a Portuguese northwestern town, this research traces the impact of migrants on the city’s development and history. Since the city’s foundation in 16 B.C. by the Romans, it saw the rule of different tribes and groups, including Suebis or Arabs. Afterwards, with the country’s establishment, the 12th century to the present, immigrants—including priests, bishops, archbishops, scholars, navigators, explorers, architects and entrepreneurs from regions such as modern-day Belgium, Italy, Spain, and France—have shaped Braga, as we know it. Additionally, the study explores the forced migration and probable influence of formerly enslaved people in the city during the Portuguese slave trade period and the few possible biographical aspects after their manumission. It also examines emigration from Braga, mainly to Brazil, during the late 19th and early 20th centuries and to Africa, specifically under Salazar’s dictatorship (1933-1974). Nowadays, the city faces a wave of Brazilian migrants, creating neologisms such as Bragasil, but also becoming attractive to migrants from new origins, such as southwest Asian countries, such as Bangladesh, adding new layers to this neverending mobility.

 

Saroj Koirala, University of Jyväskylä: Seeking Greener Pastures: conceptualizing rahar and badhyata in Nepali culture of migration

Drawing upon the data from ethnographic study on aspiring labour migrants and international students, this study exposes the culture of migration in Nepali society, conceptualizing the role of rahar (desire) and badhyata (compulsion) in shaping migration choices. The study argues that both cohorts, despite having heterogeneous backgrounds, share common elements of rahar and badhyata in their migration choices. Economic adversities, absence of desired opportunities, scepticism about better future and a general lack of hope inside the country produce elements of badhyata to migrate from Nepal. People’s elevated life aspiration influenced by media depiction, success stories of migrant ‘role models’ and perceived social status, on the other hand produce elements of rahar fostering migration in Nepal. Rahar and badhyata together contribute to the formation of distinct culture of migration, where going abroad in any possible way is viewed as a normative step towards securing a better future and achieving upward mobility in Nepal.

Session 2

Zahra Hosseini, University of Helsinki: From Integration to Satisfaction: Immigrant Women’s Experiences in Finland

As part of the Trust-M project, and in line with the 2030 Sustainable Development Goal 16, this study investigated immigrants’ experiences with public services in Finland. The research involved semi-structured interviews conducted in Persian with ten female immigrants of varying educational backgrounds (from diploma to postdoctoral), ages (30-64), lengths of residency (5-28 years), modes of entry (study visa, asylum seeker, and family reunification), and marital statuses, residing in different cities across Finland. Participants generally perceived Finland as a country of beautiful nature, safety, respect for silence and privacy, and predictably cold weather. However, they contested the widespread notion of Finland as a land of universally happy people. Moreover, the public healthcare and education systems did not meet their expectations. A comparative analysis of immigrants’ initial and subsequent perceptions of public services revealed that refugees who were resettled in Finland by the United Nations and supported by integration programs experienced a gradual shift from negative to positive feelings, leading to increased life satisfaction. Conversely, immigrants who entered Finland with a study residence permit encountered greater challenges and disappointment in their integration process, resulting in decreased life satisfaction. Along with the crucial role of integration programs offered to refugees, the study highlights the importance of communication support from family members, ethnic communities, and access to information in shaping immigrants’ trust, sense of belonging, and overall satisfaction with life in Finland.

 

Xinwei Zhang, University of Helsinki: Bubble Tea as a Cultural Anchor: Asian Migrants and the Normativity of Cultural Adaptation in Europe

This paper examines the role of bubble tea as a cultural anchor for Asian migrants in Europe, exploring how this popular beverage transcends its culinary origins to become a significant element in the adaptation and identity formation processes of migrant communities. The study investigates the journey of bubble tea from its introduction in Asia to its establishment in European markets, where it serves as both an economic strategy and a means of maintaining cultural continuity. Through ethnographic research and sociocultural analysis, the paper highlights how bubble tea facilitates the negotiation of identity and belonging among Asian migrants, reflecting broader patterns of cultural adaptation and resilience. In the context of migration as a normative behavior, this research demonstrates how food practices, such as the popularization of bubble tea, are not merely about sustenance but are deeply embedded in the socio-cultural fabric of migrant life. Bubble tea becomes a medium through which migrants express their heritage, navigate their new environments, and forge connections within their communities. The paper argues that the widespread adoption of bubble tea in Europe illustrates the fluidity of cultural practices in the face of migration, underscoring the ways in which migrants reshape and redefine their identities in response to the challenges of displacement and integration. This study contributes to the conference theme by exploring how migration, often seen as a norm in a globalized world, drives the evolution of cultural practices and creates new cultural norms within host societies.

 

Sumeera Hassan, University of Helsinki: “Navigating Persecution and Belonging: The Integration of Ahmadiyya Refugees in Finland”

The Ahmadiyya community has faced persecution from both the Pakistani government and fundamentalist groups due to their religious beliefs. As a result, many Ahmadis have sought refuge in European countries, including Finland. Compared to other European nations, the Ahmadiyya diaspora in Finland is relatively new. These refugee families encounter significant challenges in navigating a political environment increasingly influenced by right-wing ideologies, despite Finland’s comparatively better human rights conditions. My research explores the narratives of integration and belonging among these newly arrived Ahmadiyya families in Finland. It argues that while the concept of ‘homeland’ remains central to the Ahmadiyya diaspora, they are actively seeking solace in Finland, striving to integrate into society while maintaining their religious values. The paper uses qualitative methodology, and the data is collected by extensive ethnography from the year 2021-2024 with the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat Finland.